Previous experience with 〜た+ことがある Grammar: Experience » 〜た+ことがある
〜たことがある says that someone has done or experienced something at least once before. It looks back over someone’s experience up to the present instead of placing one event at a stated past time.
The negative 〜たことがない means that someone has never had that experience.
With a past reference point, ある and ない can become あった and なかった .
Contents Usage Notes Formation Saying that an experience exists Asking about experience Polite あります Saying that an experience does not exist Recalling a past occasion with ことがあった が, は, and no particle Do not confuse the form before こと Related Grammar Examples Supplemental Examples ☰ ContentsUsage Notes Formation Saying that an experience exists Asking about experience Polite あります Saying that an experience does not exist Recalling a past occasion with ことがあった が, は, and no particle Do not confuse the form before こと Related Grammar Examples Supplemental Examples Usage Notes Put the verb in its plain past form before こと . The final ある says that such an experience exists. Change ある to ない to say that it does not.
The word after こと carries the tense and politeness of the full pattern: ことがある, ことがあります, ことがない, and ことがあった. The verb before こと stays in the past form.
In conversation, speakers often omit が and say 〜たことある, 〜たことない, or 〜たことあります.
View formation details こと turns the past-form clause before it into a noun phrase. がある then presents that past action as an experience someone has had.
Verb (plain past) + ことがある 富士山( ふじさん ) に登( のぼ ) ったことがある "I have climbed Mount Fuji before." Verb (plain past) + ことがない 納豆( なっとう ) を食( た ) べたことがない "I have never eaten natto." Verb (plain past) + ことがありますか 日本( にほん ) へ行( い ) ったことがありますか "Have you ever been to Japan?" Verb (plain past) + ことがあった 子供( こども ) のころ、一人( ひとり ) で留守番( るすばん ) をしたことがあった "There was a time when I stayed home alone as a child." ことある・ことない (casual omission of が) 見( み ) たことある ?/見( み ) たことない "Have you seen it before? / I have never seen it." Saying that an experience exists The affirmative 〜たことがある treats a past action as part of someone’s experience. It does not identify when the action happened.
ご注文はうさぎですか? » Volume 1 » Page 19Talking about drawing, Cocoa is boastful of her own ability.
ココア: 「これでも金賞( きんしょう ) もらっ たことある んだ」 “Believe it or not, I've actually won a gold medal before.” リゼ: 「町内会( ちょうないかい ) の小学生( しょうがくせい ) 低学年( ていがくねん ) の部( ぶ ) とかいうのはナシな」 “And don't tell me it was in the neighborhood association's lower-elementary division.” Challenge Yourself Show Translation
Challenge
What does ココア mean in the highlighted line?
ココア: 「これでも金賞( きんしょう ) もらっ たことある んだ」 リゼ: 「町内会( ちょうないかい ) の小学生( しょうがくせい ) 低学年( ていがくねん ) の部( ぶ ) とかいうのはナシな」 Clues もらったことある もらったことある presents the prize as past experience What does the speaker mean? Believe it or not, I've actually won a gold medal before. Cocoa says that receiving a gold prize is part of her experience, without locating the award at a stated past time. Cocoa says she expects to win a gold prize in the future. The highlighted form is もらったことある. Here もらったことある presents the prize as past experience, so this choice does not match the Japanese. Cocoa says she once borrowed someone else's gold prize. The highlighted form is もらったことある. Here もらったことある presents the prize as past experience, so this choice does not match the Japanese. Cocoa admits that she has never entered an art contest. The highlighted form is もらったことある. Here もらったことある presents the prize as past experience, so this choice does not match the Japanese.
もらったことある presents the prize as past experience. Cocoa says that receiving a gold prize is part of her experience, without locating the award at a stated past time.
View Full Example Cocoa presents winning a gold prize as evidence of her drawing ability. She does not say when she won it. Her casual もらったことある omits が.
ARIA The MASTERPIECE » Volume 4 » Page 152Akari and President Aria walk with Alicia to her meeting location. Rather than head back home, Akari and President Aria decide to sit at the café across the street until the meeting is over. There, Akari notices a gentleman sitting at another table.
灯里( あかり ) :「あのおじさんどこかで会( あ ) ったことがある ような?」 “It feels like I have met that man somewhere before.” View Full Example 会( あ ) ったことがある says that meeting the man belongs to Akari’s past experience. The ending ような shows that she cannot place the memory with confidence.
三ツ星カラーズ » Volume 5 » Page 115Sacchan and her friends come across a torn piece of paper with 「あたり100」 written on it. Thinking it may be for a 100,000 yen prize, the girls head to the shopping district to redeem it. Along the way, their friend Nonoko says she doesn’t recognize where the ticket is from, but Sacchan’s mother says it looks familiar somehow. Kotoha admits it seemed familiar to her as well, but she thought it was just her imagination until now.
結衣( ゆい ) :「私( わたし ) とさっちゃんとののちゃんは知( し ) らなくて」 “Even though Sacchan, Nono-chan, and I don't know it...” さっちゃん: 「かーちゃんと琴( こと ) ちゃんは見( み ) たことがある 」 “My mom and Koto-chan have seen it before.” Challenge Yourself Show Translation
Challenge
Who does Sacchan say has seen the mysterious ticket before?
結衣( ゆい ) :「私( わたし ) とさっちゃんとののちゃんは知( し ) らなくて」 さっちゃん: 「かーちゃんと琴( こと ) ちゃんは見( み ) たことがある 」 Clues 私( わたし ) とさっちゃんとののちゃんは知( し ) らなくて Yui, Sacchan, and Nono-chan do not recognize it かーちゃんと琴( こと ) ちゃんは見( み ) たことがある Mom and Koto-chan have seen it before What does the speaker mean? Sacchan's mother and Kotoha. かーちゃんと琴( こと ) ちゃん are the people marked as having the experience 見( み ) たことがある. Yui, Sacchan, and Nono-chan. Those three are followed by 知( し ) らなくて, so they do not recognize it. Only Sacchan's mother. と joins かーちゃん and 琴( こと ) ちゃん as two people with the experience. Only Kotoha. Sacchan includes both Kotoha and her mother. Yui and Kotoha. Yui places herself among those who do not know it, while Kotoha is in the experienced group. Sacchan and her mother. Sacchan says she does not recognize it. Her mother and Kotoha do.
Sacchan divides the group in two. Yui, Sacchan, and Nono-chan do not recognize the ticket, but Sacchan’s mother and Kotoha have seen it before.
View Full Example Here 見( み ) たことがある explains why the ticket seems familiar. The pattern points back to an earlier sighting rather than the act of looking at it now.
Asking about experience An affirmative question asks whether the listener has ever had the experience. Casual speech can use 〜たことある? . Polite speech commonly uses 〜たことがありますか .
ご注文はうさぎですか? » Volume 1 » Page 63After a misunderstanding brings Cocoa and her friends to the teahouse where Syaro works, the group stays to have some tea.
ココア: 「やっぱダンディー・ライオンだよね!」 “Dandy Lion is definitely the one!” チノ: 「飲( の ) んだことある んですか?」 “Have you drunk it before?” Challenge Yourself Show Translation
Challenge
What does チノ mean in the highlighted line?
ココア: 「やっぱダンディー・ライオンだよね!」 チノ: 「飲( の ) んだことある んですか?」 Clues 飲( の ) んだことある 飲( の ) んだことある asks about prior experienceWhat does the speaker mean? Have you drunk it before? Chino asks whether Cocoa has ever drunk dandelion tea, rather than whether she drank it at one known time. Chino asks whether Cocoa is drinking dandelion tea right now. The highlighted form is 飲( の ) んだことある. Here 飲( の ) んだことある asks about prior experience, so this choice does not match the Japanese. Chino states that Cocoa has definitely drunk it before. The highlighted form is 飲( の ) んだことある. Here 飲( の ) んだことある asks about prior experience, so this choice does not match the Japanese. Chino asks whether Cocoa wants to try the tea for the first time. The highlighted form is 飲( の ) んだことある. Here 飲( の ) んだことある asks about prior experience, so this choice does not match the Japanese.
飲( の ) んだことある asks about prior experience. Chino asks whether Cocoa has ever drunk dandelion tea, rather than whether she drank it at one known time.
View Full Example Chino asks whether Cocoa has drunk dandelion tea before. The line is conversational, so が is absent. The explanatory んですか connects the question to Cocoa’s confident choice.
Polite あります Replacing ある with あります makes the pattern polite. が can still disappear in conversation.
ご注文はうさぎですか? » Volume 1 » Page 52Rize and Chino watch as Cocoa and another girl reach for the same teacup in a shop.
チノ: 「こんなシチュエーション漫画( まんが ) でみ たことあります 」 “I've seen this kind of situation in manga before.” リゼ: 「よく恋愛( れんあい ) に発展( はってん ) するよな」 “This kind of thing often leads to romance.” Challenge Yourself Show Translation
Challenge
What does チノ mean in the highlighted line?
チノ: 「こんなシチュエーション漫画( まんが ) でみ たことあります 」 リゼ: 「よく恋愛( れんあい ) に発展( はってん ) するよな」 Clues みたことあります 見( み ) たことあります reports prior experienceWhat does the speaker mean? I've seen this kind of situation in manga before. Chino says she has encountered this kind of scene in manga before. Chino says the current encounter is taking place inside a manga. The highlighted form is みたことあります. Here 見( み ) たことあります reports prior experience, so this choice does not match the Japanese. Chino says she has never seen a scene like this before. The highlighted form is みたことあります. Here 見( み ) たことあります reports prior experience, so this choice does not match the Japanese. Chino says she has seen romance in manga, but not this situation. The highlighted form is みたことあります. Here 見( み ) たことあります reports prior experience, so this choice does not match the Japanese.
見( み ) たことあります reports prior experience. Chino says she has encountered this kind of scene in manga before.
View Full Example Chino’s みたことあります is polite because of あります, even though she omits が.
Saying that an experience does not exist The negative 〜たことがない says that the person has never done something. In casual speech, が is often omitted: 〜たことない .
あずまんが大王 » Volume 1年生 » Page 132Chiyo shows her friends in class the panda picture book she bought.
歩( あゆむ ) :「私( わたし ) パンダてまだ見( み ) たことない ねん」 “I haven't seen a panda yet.” とも: 「私( わたし ) 見( み ) たことあるよ ありゃかわいーよー」 “I've seen one. They're cute!” Challenge Yourself Show Translation
Challenge
How do Ayumu's and Tomo's panda experiences differ?
歩( あゆむ ) :「私( わたし ) パンダてまだ見( み ) たことないねん」 とも: 「私( わたし ) 見( み ) たことあるよ ありゃかわいーよー」 Clues まだ見( み ) たことない has not seen one yet 見( み ) たことある has seen one before ありゃかわいーよ those are cute What does the speaker mean? Ayumu has never seen a panda, while Tomo has and says they are cute. Ayumu uses 見( み ) たことない, while Tomo answers with the affirmative 見( み ) たことある and comments that pandas are cute. Ayumu has seen a panda, while Tomo has not. This swaps the two experiences. Ayumu uses ない, and Tomo uses ある. Neither girl has ever seen a panda. Tomo explicitly says 見( み ) たことある, so she has seen one. Both girls have seen pandas and found them cute. Ayumu's まだ見( み ) たことない says she has not seen one yet. Ayumu saw a panda recently but Tomo saw one long ago. Ayumu describes no past viewing at all. まだ with the negative means not yet. Tomo has seen the picture book but not a real panda. Tomo's 見( み ) たことある answers Ayumu's statement about seeing a panda, not about seeing the book.
Ayumu says she has never seen a panda yet. Tomo contrasts that with her own experience and adds that pandas are cute.
View Full Example ホリミヤ » Volume 11 » Page 70Yanagi speaks politely to everyone in the group, though he talks casually with Yuki. Iura tells him to call everyone by their first names and announces that he’ll call Yanagi “Akane” from now on. Then he asks Yanagi to call him by his first name too.
柳( やなぎ ) :「友達( ともだち ) のこと名前( なまえ ) で呼( よ ) んだことあんまりない ので…」 “I've hardly ever called my friends by their names, so...” 「急( きゅう ) にはちょっと難( むずか ) しいです」 “It's a little hard to do all of a sudden.” Challenge Yourself Show Translation
Challenge
Why does Yanagi hesitate to call Iura by his first name?
柳( やなぎ ) :「友達( ともだち ) のこと 名前( なまえ ) で呼( よ ) んだことあんまりないので…」 「急( きゅう ) にはちょっと難( むずか ) しいです」 Clues 友達( ともだち ) のこと名前( なまえ ) で呼( よ ) ぶ call friends by their names 〜たことあんまりない have hardly ever done 急( きゅう ) には all of a sudden What does the speaker mean? He has hardly ever called friends by their first names, so switching all at once is hard. 呼( よ ) んだことあんまりない gives his lack of practice as the reason, and 急( きゅう ) には難( むずか ) しい says the sudden change is the problem. His friends have hardly ever called him by his first name. のこと follows 友達( ともだち ) , so his friends are the ones being named. Yanagi is the one doing the calling. He doesn't think of Iura as a friend. He's talking about friends in general. Nothing he says leaves Iura out. He doesn't know Iura's first name. The problem is habit, not knowledge. He says it's hard to do all of a sudden.
友達( ともだち ) のこと名前( なまえ ) で呼( よ ) んだことあんまりない means “I’ve hardly ever called friends by their names”. のこと marks the people being named, で marks how they’re addressed, and the を has dropped. Yanagi gives his lack of practice as the reason with ので and trails off, then softens the refusal with ちょっと. He says it all with です, the polite speech Iura wants him to drop.
View Full Example のんのんびより » Volume 5 » Page 77Hotaru and Komari agreed to trade homemade lunches while viewing the cherry blossoms. Komari’s lunch came out badly, with burnt noodles and a hamburger covered in melted chocolate, but Hotaru ate it anyway and insisted it was delicious. Now Komari offers her a rice ball, and Hotaru takes a bite and finds it good.
小鞠( こまり ) :「私( わたし ) お米( こめ ) 炊( た ) くのは失敗( しっぱい ) し たことあるけどおにぎり握( にぎ ) るのは失敗( しっぱい ) したことない んだー」 “I've messed up cooking rice before, but I've never messed up making rice balls!” 蛍( ほたる ) :「おにぎりの中身( なかみ ) なんですか?」 “What's in the rice balls?” 小鞠( こまり ) :「んーとね 梅干( うめぼ ) しとおかかとしゃけとかかな? お母( かあ ) さんが作( つく ) った野沢菜( のざわな ) のもあるよ」 “Let's see... pickled plum, bonito flakes, salmon, that kind of thing? There's also one with the nozawana pickles my mom made.” 蛍( ほたる ) :「へー 野沢菜( のざわな ) ですか?」 “Oh, nozawana?” 「良( よ ) かった… 普通( ふつう ) だ…」 “Thank goodness... They're normal...” Challenge Yourself Show Translation
Challenge
What is Komari proud of?
小鞠( こまり ) :「私( わたし ) お米( こめ ) 炊( た ) くのは失敗( しっぱい ) したことあるけどおにぎり握( にぎ ) る のは失敗( しっぱい ) したことないんだー」 蛍( ほたる ) :「おにぎりの中身( なかみ ) なんですか?」 小鞠( こまり ) :「んーとね 梅干( うめぼ ) しとおかかとしゃけとかかな? お母( かあ ) さんが作( つく ) った野沢菜( のざわな ) のもあるよ」 蛍( ほたる ) :「へー 野沢菜( のざわな ) ですか?」 「良( よ ) かった… 普通( ふつう ) だ…」 Clues お米( こめ ) 炊( た ) く to cook rice おにぎり握( にぎ ) る to shape rice balls by hand 〜のは turns the action before it into a topic, "as for doing ~" 失敗( しっぱい ) したことある・ない have failed before / have never failed What does the speaker mean? She has failed at cooking rice, but never at shaping rice balls. お米( こめ ) 炊( た ) く is the cooking step, and おにぎり握( にぎ ) る is shaping the cooked rice by hand. She admits failing at the first and claims a perfect record at the second. She has never failed at cooking rice or at making rice balls. The first half says 失敗( しっぱい ) したことある, so she has messed up cooking rice before. She is good at cooking rice but bad at shaping rice balls. It's the other way around. ある goes with cooking rice, ない goes with rice balls. She has never tried making rice balls before. 失敗( しっぱい ) したことない says she has never failed at it, not that she has never done it.
Komari sets two cooking verbs side by side. お米( こめ ) を炊( た ) く is cooking the rice, and おにぎりを握( にぎ ) る is pressing that rice into balls by hand. Each takes の and は to become a topic, and each gets its own experience phrase. She has failed at cooking rice (したことある), but never at rice balls (したことない). After the lunch Hotaru just ate, the rice ball is something Komari can promise is safe.
View Full Example 舞妓さんちのまかないさん » Volume 15 » Page 54Kiyo and Sumire visit a Western-style restaurant whose card their childhood friend Kenta left them, guessing he works there as a waiter. When they can’t cover the bill, the woman serving them says a staff member already paid for their meal out of his wages. That turns out to be Kenta, who works in the kitchen as an apprentice cook. Sumire admits the news surprised them, since Kenta never used to cook.
店員( てんいん ) さん:「本人( ほんにん ) も面接( めんせつ ) で『包丁( ほうちょう ) もにぎっ たことありません 』て言( ゆ ) うてはったわ。」 “He said so himself at his interview. 'I've never even held a kitchen knife.'” ー: 「ばか正直( しょうじき ) 」 “Honest to a fault” Challenge Yourself Show Translation
Challenge
What did Kenta tell the restaurant at his job interview?
店員( てんいん ) さん:「本人( ほんにん ) も面接( めんせつ ) で『包丁( ほうちょう ) もにぎった ことありません』て言( ゆ ) うてはったわ。」 ー: 「ばか正直( しょうじき ) 」 Clues 本人( ほんにん ) the person in question, here Kenta himself 面接( めんせつ ) an interview 包丁( ほうちょう ) a kitchen knife にぎった past form of 握( にぎ ) る, to grip or hold tight 〜たことありません polite way to say you have never done something 言( ゆ ) うてはった Kyoto speech for 言( い ) っていた, "was saying" What does the speaker mean? He had never even held a kitchen knife. 包丁( ほうちょう ) を握( にぎ ) る means to take up a kitchen knife, and も with a negative means "not even". Kenta admitted he had never cooked at all. He had never sharpened a kitchen knife. Sharpening a knife is 包丁( ほうちょう ) を研( と ) ぐ. にぎった comes from 握( にぎ ) る, to grip. He had held a kitchen knife only once. ありません denies the experience. 〜たことありません means he has never done it, not that he did it once. He promised never to pick up a knife again. 〜たことがない looks back at past experience. It isn't a vow about the future.
The restaurant woman quotes Kenta’s interview. He told them plainly that he had never even held a kitchen knife, and the label ばか正直( しょうじき ) calls him honest to a fault. 包丁( ほうちょう ) を握( にぎ ) る is how Japanese talks about taking up cooking, so 包丁( ほうちょう ) も握( にぎ ) ったことがない means someone has never cooked at all.
View Full Example Recalling a past occasion with ことがあった The past 〜たことがあった can recall an occasion that existed in an earlier period. English often translates it as “there was a time when” or simply “once.”
ご注文はうさぎですか? » Volume 1 » Page 116Rize wonders what became of the missing piece from Chiya’s puzzle. Syaro suggets it’ll turn up once it’s no longer being looked for. This reminds Chiya of something else that was forgotten.
千夜( ちや ) :「シャロちゃんは学校( がっこう ) にランドセルを忘( わす ) れたまま帰( かえ ) ってきた事( こと ) があった わ」 “Syaro-chan once came home having left her backpack at school.” シャロ: 「明日( あした ) 学校( がっこう ) 行( い ) けない…」 “I can't go to school tomorrow...” Challenge Yourself Show Translation
Challenge
What does 千夜( ちや ) mean in the highlighted line?
千夜( ちや ) :「シャロちゃんは学校( がっこう ) にランドセルを忘( わす ) れたまま帰( かえ ) ってきた事( こと ) があった わ」 シャロ: 「明日( あした ) 学校( がっこう ) 行( い ) けない…」 Clues 帰( かえ ) ってきた事( こと ) があった 帰( かえ ) ってきた事( こと ) があった reports a past experienceWhat does the speaker mean? Syaro-chan once came home having left her backpack at school. Chiya says there was an occasion when Syaro came home after leaving her backpack at school. Syaro once forgot her backpack at home and returned to school for it. The highlighted form is 帰( かえ ) ってきた事( こと ) があった. Here 帰( かえ ) ってきた事( こと ) があった reports a past experience, so this choice does not match the Japanese. Syaro came home without her backpack every day. The highlighted form is 帰( かえ ) ってきた事( こと ) があった. Here 帰( かえ ) ってきた事( こと ) があった reports a past experience, so this choice does not match the Japanese. Chiya says Syaro has never forgotten her backpack at school. The highlighted form is 帰( かえ ) ってきた事( こと ) があった. Here 帰( かえ ) ってきた事( こと ) があった reports a past experience, so this choice does not match the Japanese.
帰( かえ ) ってきた事( こと ) があった reports a past experience. Chiya says there was an occasion when Syaro came home after leaving her backpack at school.
View Full Example が, は, and no particle が is the neutral particle in this pattern. Conversation often drops it, as several examples above do.
は adds contrast. 食( た ) べたことはある can mean “I have eaten it, at least,” often before a qualification. In the negative, 食( た ) べたことはない puts contrastive weight on the lack of that experience.
葬送のフリーレン » Volume 3 » Page 104Frieren has defeated Aura the Guillotine, whose undead army was made of fallen northern warriors. Count Granat thanks the party for bringing the warriors down with so little damage to their bodies, and orders his soldiers to give them a proper burial. Among the bodies, he finds a suit of armor with the Granat family crest hanging from its neck. It belonged to his son, who died in battle.
グラナト伯爵( はくしゃく ) : 「…フリーレン。」 “...Frieren.” 「儂( わし ) は今日( きょう ) ほど誰( だれ ) かに感謝( かんしゃ ) したことはない 。」 “I have never been as grateful to anyone as I am today.” Challenge Yourself Show Translation
Challenge
What is Count Granat telling Frieren?
グラナト伯爵( はくしゃく ) : 「…フリーレン。」 「儂( わし ) は今日( きょう ) ほど 誰( だれ ) かに感謝( かんしゃ ) したことはない 。」 Clues 今日( きょう ) ほど as much as today 誰( だれ ) かに感謝( かんしゃ ) する to be grateful to someone 〜たことはない have never done What does the speaker mean? He has never been as grateful to anyone as he is today. 今日( きょう ) ほど makes today the yardstick, and したことはない says no earlier time ever reached it. Today is the most grateful he has ever been. He has never thanked anyone before today. ほど compares how grateful he is, not whether he has ever been grateful. He has been grateful before, just never this much. He was once more grateful to someone else than he is today. ほど with a negative says the other cases fall short of today. Nothing goes beyond it. He is about as grateful today as he usually is. The pattern sets today apart from every other time. It doesn't put today on a level with them.
今日( きょう ) ほど〜したことはない means “have never done ~ as much as today”. ほど sets today as the standard, and 〜たことはない says no past experience reaches it. The count is saying that today he is more grateful than he has ever been.
View Full Example The verb form before こと changes the meaning.
Pattern Meaning 〜たことがある have done before 〜ることがある sometimes do 〜ないことがある sometimes do not do 〜たいことがある have something one wants to do
Examples Grammar Explanation: Previous experience with 〜た+ことがある
ご注文はうさぎですか? » Volume 1 » Page 69Cocoa thinks Rize is nervous about staying overnight with her and Chino.
リゼ: 「いや… 親父( おやじ ) の部下( ぶか ) に誘( さそ ) われたワイルドなキャンプしか経験( けいけん ) した事( こと ) ない から…」 “Well... I've only had the experience of those wild camping trips my dad's subordinates invited me on...” 「こんなの初( はじ ) めてで…」 “I've never done anything like this before...” ココア: 「ワイルド?」 “Wild?” Challenge Yourself Show Translation
Challenge
What does リゼ mean in the highlighted line? Clues 経験( けいけん ) した事( こと ) ない 〜た事( こと ) がある = have had the experience of... What does the speaker mean? Well... I've only had the experience of those wild camping trips my dad's subordinates invited me on... The highlighted pattern expresses past experience at least once. Rize says she often attends ordinary sleepovers with friends. The highlighted form is 経験( けいけん ) した事( こと ) ない. Here 〜た事( こと ) がある = have had the experience of..., so this choice does not match the Japanese. Rize says she has never gone camping before. The highlighted form is 経験( けいけん ) した事( こと ) ない. Here 〜た事( こと ) がある = have had the experience of..., so this choice does not match the Japanese. Rize says she invited her father's subordinates to stay at her home. The highlighted form is 経験( けいけん ) した事( こと ) ない. Here 〜た事( こと ) がある = have had the experience of..., so this choice does not match the Japanese.
〜た事( こと ) がある = have had the experience of…. The highlighted pattern expresses past experience at least once.
Supplemental Examples Try finding this grammar in the following examples: